KINDLEFALL Play free
Part 12

Making the boons delight the eye

Five art directions tried on ten boons, and why the living icons won.

A boon is the moment a run changes. Three cards rise from a shrine, you weigh them, you pick one. The card's icon is the first thing your eye lands on, and it shows up again in the corner of the screen for the rest of the run. For a long time those icons were placeholders, and some didn't even show their boon. Will-o'-Wisp, a chance to slip out of a hit, was drawn as an eye. Glass Cannon was a gem. Circling Embers was two dots and a ring.

So before redrawing all of them, we ran an experiment: five different art directions, each tried on the same ten boons, compared side by side at the sizes the game actually uses.

Ten boons, five directions

The ten were picked to cover every kind of boon and every kind of problem: Searing Edge (Blade), Circling Embers (Ember), Will-o'-Wisp (Grace), Iron Will (Vigour), Glass Cannon (Pact), Chain Lightning (Storm), Heart of the Forge (a relic), Wheel of Fire (a duo), World Splitter (the Barbarian's legendary) and Shard of the Fall, the new signature relic. The "before" column isn't a mock-up: it was extracted from the game itself, so it's exactly what the game draws today.

A comparison sheet: ten boons in rows (Searing Edge, Circling Embers, Will-o'-Wisp, Iron Will, Glass Cannon, Chain Lightning, Heart of the Forge, Wheel of Fire, World Splitter, Shard of the Fall), each shown as the current icon and in five new styles (refined painted, forged medallion, baked 3D, living, engraved), at card size with a small HUD-size chip beneath each
The comparison sheetEach column at card size (a 96 px plate), with the 28 px HUD chip under it. Open the full-size sheet (3336×3988, 3.8 MB).

The pick: living icons

The winner was D, the living set: the painted art, with gentle motion where your eye rests, and one plain circle behind every icon. Each loop is short, under three seconds, and acts the boon out. Circling Embers' fireballs really pass behind the hero and in front of him. Chain Lightning hops from skull to skull in sequence. Will-o'-Wisp slips aside as a strike passes through its ghost. Wheel of Fire spins, because the boon makes it spin "twice as fast". World Splitter lifts its maul and slams, and the three rings run out in turn.

The living set in motionRecorded by stepping the icons' own animation clocks frame by frame, so the motion is exact.

The motion is designed to be safe to stop. Frozen at any moment, a living icon is still the painted icon, so screenshots, the small HUD row and players who turn on reduced motion all get a good still. It needs no script: the animation lives inside the image file, and the operating system's reduced-motion setting turns it off. It's also used only where your eye actually rests: the shrine card you're looking at, the open Codex entry, the Hollow King's theft close-up. The 24 px HUD row and a full Codex grid stay still, because an animated image is re-drawn every frame it's on screen.

Spot-check frames of the living icons at several moments of their loops, showing each animation's poses
Frames from the loopsEvery pose holds up as a still.

Why the others lost

What it costs

SetBytes per icongzippedfirst draw at 96 px
Before1.4 KB0.5 KB0.1 ms
A · Refined painted5.3 KB1.4 KB0.3 ms
B · Forged medallions8.4 KB1.9 KB1.1 ms
C · Real 3D, baked (256 px image)74 KB74 KB0.1 ms
D · Living6.6 KB1.6 KB0.3 ms, then redrawn while visible
E · Engraved6.2 KB1.4 KB0.4 ms

A living icon costs about 1.6 KB over the network, a little more than a kilobyte above today's icons, and draws as fast as the painted set. The experiment's own measurements agree closely; ours differ by at most 0.3 ms on the first draw.

Measured onAverages over the ten experiment icons per set. Gzip at level 9. "First draw" = decode the icon and draw it into a 96 px canvas, median of 60 runs, Chrome 154 with Metal on a MacBook Pro, Apple M3 Max.

What's next

The game has 237 boons, duos, relics and blessings, and every one of them gets redrawn in the living style, school by school, each batch checked on a before-and-after sheet like the one above before it ships. Most of the motion comes for free: flames flicker for the Ember school, lightning hops for Storm, hearts pulse for Vigour, so a new boon gets life from its school's motion as soon as it's drawn.

Play Kindlefall

In your browser, with a keyboard and mouse or a controller.